Key takeaways
- Pennsylvania requires 3 background checks for anyone with direct contact with students, including people working through a contractor, and a school administrator must review them before the first day.
- Under 34 CFR 300.156(b), related services personnel must hold the state license for their discipline, not waived on an emergency, temporary or provisional basis.
- Before 2024-25, 64% of public schools named a lack of qualified candidates and 62% named too few applicants, which is why who recruits and who else the agency supplies are 2 of the 7 questions.
- Score each of the 7 answers 0, 1 or 2 for a total out of 14, and give a 2 only to an answer backed by a document, a named school or a contract clause.
- FocusedEDU answers all 7 in writing: files finished before you meet a candidate, one partner per market, and temp-to-perm with no conversion fee and no buyout.
In this article
- What should you ask a K-12 staffing agency before you sign?
- What are the 7 questions, and what does a strong answer sound like?
- What background checks and qualifications do the rules require for adults who work in your schools?
- What must a district document for contracted personnel?
- How do you score the answers and compare 2 or 3 agencies side by side?
- How does FocusedEDU answer the 7 questions?
To choose a K-12 staffing agency, ask it 7 things before you sign: who finishes clearances and credential files, how fast a start happens, who recruits and interviews, whether it supplies competing schools nearby, what a permanent hire costs, its fill and retention results with named references, and its fix for a wrong fit. Pennsylvania alone requires 3 background checks per person.
What should you ask a K-12 staffing agency before you sign?
Ask the 7 questions in the table below, in this order, and get each answer in writing. All 7 fit in one 30-minute call.
Each question has an answer you can check. Before the 2024-25 school year, 74% of public schools reported difficulty filling 1 or more vacant teaching positions. The 2 challenges they named most were a lack of qualified candidates (64%) and too few candidates applying (62%) (source: NCES School Pulse Panel, October 17, 2024 release).
| Question to ask | Why it decides the outcome | Get this in writing |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Are clearances and the credential file finished before I meet a candidate? | Your administrator must review those checks before anyone works with students. | The checks run for your state, and a sample file. |
| 2. How long from my request to a start, and what is that number based on? | An open seat costs you every week it stays open. | Days from request to start, at a named school. |
| 3. Who recruits and interviews the candidates you send me? | A forwarded résumé leaves the screening on your desk. | The steps a candidate passes before you see a name. |
| 4. Do you supply competing schools in my area? | A shared pool goes to whoever pays more. | An exclusivity clause for your market. |
| 5. What does it cost to hire the person permanently? | A buyout charges you for keeping the person who worked out. | The conversion terms, with the dollar figure. |
| 6. What are your fill and retention results, and who can I call? | A number with a school's name on it can be checked. | Results at a named school, and signed references. |
| 7. What happens when a placement is not right? | You answer for the contract for its whole term. | The replacement terms and your contact's name. |
What are the 7 questions, and what does a strong answer sound like?
A strong answer names a document, a number or a person. A weak answer is an adjective. Each question below has both, with the rule or fact behind it.
Question 1: Are clearances and the credential file finished before I meet a candidate?
- Strong: names every check your state requires, confirms the certificate or license is verified, sends the file with the candidate and tracks expiration dates.
- Weak: "We start the paperwork once you choose someone," or "the candidate brings their own clearances."
The rule behind it: in Pennsylvania, a school administrator must review all 3 background check reports and decide the person's fitness to work with children. That review "is required PRIOR to the applicant working in a school" (source: Pennsylvania Department of Education, federal criminal history record information). An agency that finishes the file first hands you a review. One that starts after your interview hands you a project.
Question 2: How long from my request to a start, and what is that number based on?
- Strong: days or weeks for your role in your state, the school where it happened, and what is already done before you interview.
- Weak: "It depends," with no example, or "tomorrow" for a certified role with no file to show.
The fact behind it: public schools filled 79% of their teaching vacancies before classes resumed in 2024-25. Special education was hardest: 74% of elementary and middle schools had difficulty filling a special education vacancy with a fully certified teacher (source: NCES School Pulse Panel, October 17, 2024 release). What each open week costs is worked out in what an unfilled classroom costs a school district.
Question 3: Who recruits and interviews the candidates you send me?
- Strong: the agency recruits against your opening, interviews every candidate itself, calls references at prior schools and sends a shortlist. You interview and decide.
- Weak: résumés forwarded from a job board, the same résumé arriving from more than 1 agency, or "meet them and tell us what you think."
The fact behind it: 64% of public schools named a lack of qualified candidates as a challenge in filling teaching vacancies (source: NCES School Pulse Panel, October 17, 2024 release). Finding and screening is the work you are paying for. For paraprofessionals, ask how training is checked. Federal rule allows them to assist with special education and related services when they are "appropriately trained and supervised" under state law, regulation or written policy (source: eCFR, 34 CFR 300.156(b)(2)(iii)).
Question 4: Do you supply competing schools in my area?
- Strong: "No. One client per market, in writing." The educators recruited for you are presented to you alone.
- Weak: "We work with every district in the county," or "our database is very large."
The fact behind it: 62% of public schools said too few candidates applied for their teaching vacancies (source: NCES School Pulse Panel, October 17, 2024 release). When the pool is that short, an agency that supplies 3 neighbors decides which one gets the certified special education teacher. With an exclusive partner, you never bid against your own agency's other clients.
Question 5: What does it cost to hire the person permanently?
- Strong: "Nothing. No conversion fee and no buyout, and it is in the agreement." You evaluate the professional on the job first.
- Weak: a fee schedule, a minimum number of hours before you may hire, or "we will work that out when the time comes."
The rule behind it: every state must require its districts to "take measurable steps to recruit, hire, train, and retain" qualified special education personnel (source: eCFR, 34 CFR 300.156(d)). A buyout puts a price on retaining the professional who has already proven themselves in your building. Replacing a teacher already costs $11,860 to $24,930 by district size (source: Learning Policy Institute, 2024 technical supplement). Our guide to education staffing contract terms shows where the clause sits, and how much a teacher staffing agency costs explains how pricing is built.
Question 6: What are your fill and retention results, and who can I call?
- Strong: a fill rate and how a fill is counted, a retention figure, both tied to a named school, with signed letters and a reference call before you sign.
- Weak: "high 90s" with no school attached, a wall of logos, or references "once the contract is in place."
The rule behind it: when a federal award pays for the purchase, you must consider the contractor's "past performance record" in awarding the contract (source: eCFR, 2 CFR 200.318(h)). A number with a school's name on it is a record. A number without one is a claim.
Question 7: What happens when a placement is not right?
- Strong: a named contact, a replacement and what it costs you, and time to evaluate before any permanent commitment.
- Weak: "email support," a new search fee, or a minimum term you pay for either way.
The rule behind it: districts spending federal funds "must maintain oversight to ensure that contractors perform in accordance with the terms, conditions, and specifications of their contracts" (source: eCFR, 2 CFR 200.318(b)). A remedy written into the agreement is a term you can hold the agency to.
What background checks and qualifications do the rules require for adults who work in your schools?
State law sets the background checks, and it reaches people who come to your students through a contractor as well as people you hire directly. Federal law adds the qualification standard for special education and a rule against passing along anyone known to have engaged in sexual misconduct.
| Rule | Who it covers | What it requires |
|---|---|---|
| Pennsylvania: School Code Section 111 (Acts 34, 151 and 114) and Act 168 | Anyone with direct contact with students, including people working through a contractor | Three checks: State Police criminal record, DHS child abuse history and the FBI fingerprint report. Each may be used for up to 60 months. Act 168 adds an employment history review (source: Pennsylvania Department of Education, clearances) (source: Pennsylvania Department of Education, acts and laws). |
| New Jersey: N.J.S.A. 18A:6-7.1 and P.L. 2018, c. 5 | Positions named in the statute, anyone with regular pupil contact, and contracted service providers | A fingerprint search by the State Police and the FBI, complete "prior to employment or service" (source: New Jersey Department of Education, criminal history FAQ). Child abuse and sexual misconduct inquiries since June 1, 2018 (source: New Jersey Department of Education, P.L. 2018, c. 5). |
| Delaware: 31 Del. C. § 309 | Public schools, for the people they hire, volunteers and contractors | A fingerprinted Delaware and national check by the State Bureau of Identification and the FBI, plus a Child Protection Registry check (source: Delaware Code, 31 Del. C. § 309). |
| Federal, IDEA: 34 CFR 300.156 | Special education teachers, related services personnel and paraprofessionals | Teachers and related services personnel: state certification or licensure for the discipline, not "waived on an emergency, temporary, or provisional basis." Paraprofessionals: "appropriately trained and supervised" under state law, regulation or written policy (source: eCFR, 34 CFR 300.156). |
| Federal, ESSA: 20 U.S.C. 7926 | Anyone who works for a school, including a contractor or agent | State and district policies that bar helping a person get a new job when there is probable cause to believe they engaged in sexual misconduct with a minor or student (source: U.S. Code, 20 U.S.C. 7926). |
In all 3 states the school keeps a duty of its own when the person arrives through an agency. In New Jersey, where a contractor has no code of its own from the Office of Student Protection, the school carries "total responsibility" for confirming that each of the contractor's people has complied (source: New Jersey Department of Education, criminal history FAQ). Delaware says all child-serving entities, public schools included, "are required to obtain criminal and Child Protection Registry checks" for contractors (source: Delaware Code, 31 Del. C. § 309(c)). That is why question 1 comes first.
What must a district document for contracted personnel?
Keep the same file for a contracted professional that you would want to show an auditor or a parent: the clearances, the credential and your own review of both. The agency can assemble the file. The review belongs to the school.
- Each state-required background check, with its date. In Pennsylvania that is all 3 reports, none older than 60 months, reviewed before the person starts.
- The employment history review. Pennsylvania's Act 168 process uses the Commonwealth's Sexual Misconduct/Abuse Disclosure Release (source: Pennsylvania Department of Education, Act 168 FAQ). New Jersey's P.L. 2018, c. 5 has its own disclosure forms.
- The state's approval, where the state issues one. In New Jersey, the person's Applicant Approval Employment History from the Office of Student Protection.
- The certificate or license for the role. For related services, confirm it is current and not waived on an emergency, temporary or provisional basis. For paraprofessionals, keep the training and supervision your state requires.
- Your procurement record, if federal funds pay for the contract. It must include "the rationale for the procurement method, contract type selection, contractor selection or rejection, and the basis for the contract price" (source: eCFR, 2 CFR 200.318(i)). If the agreement pays by the hour, federal rules treat it as a time-and-materials contract: file a determination that no other contract type is suitable, and write a ceiling price into the agreement (source: eCFR, 2 CFR 200.318(j)).
If you are writing a solicitation, turn the 7 questions into required exhibits and scored evaluation factors. On a federally funded request for proposals, "all evaluation factors and their relative importance must be identified" in the notice, and you must have written procedures for the evaluation (source: eCFR, 2 CFR 200.320(b)(2)). The scorecard gives you both. Our RFP requirements checklist lists what to request, and our RFP and contract experience shows how we respond.
How do you score the answers and compare 2 or 3 agencies side by side?
Score each answer 0, 1 or 2, add the 7 scores and compare totals out of 14. Use the same sheet and the same wording for every agency.
| Score | What you heard | What it sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | A specific answer backed by a document, a number tied to a named school or a clause in the agreement | "No conversion fee. Here is the clause, and here is a letter from a school that used it." |
| 1 | A specific answer in words only | "We usually fill in a few weeks." |
| 0 | No answer, an adjective, or a promise to follow up | "Our candidates are top quality." |
- Score during the call. Tick the lines you hear under each question.
- Ask for the document within 2 business days. A 2 drops to a 1 if the file, the clause or the reference never arrives.
- Treat question 1 as pass or fail. A 0 on the credential file ends the comparison for that agency, because the review of those checks is yours under state law.
- Break ties on questions 4 and 5. Exclusivity and the cost of a permanent hire keep paying you back after the first placement.
In a planning example, Agency A answers all 7 questions in words and scores 7. Agency B backs 5 answers with documents, answers 2 in words and scores 12. B leads because 5 of its answers can be checked.
The K-12 Staffing Partner Scorecard on this page puts the 7 questions on paper with the things to listen for under each. Keep the completed sheets as your record of contractor selection or rejection.
How does FocusedEDU answer the 7 questions?
The same way every time, in writing. More on how districts score us is on our school district staffing vendor page.
- The credential file. Automated credentialing, background checks and documentation are handled before a candidate ever reaches you. In Pennsylvania that means Act 34 criminal history, Act 151 child abuse and Act 114 FBI fingerprinting, with equivalent clearances for Delaware, New Jersey and Maryland placements. Our system tracks every clearance and certification, flags expirations before they lapse and keeps files audit-ready.
- Time to a start. Automated credentialing cuts hiring time in half. At First Philadelphia Public Charter School and at IDEA Public Charter School, every open certified special education teacher role was filled within 2 weeks of the request.
- Who recruits. We source against your specific openings, interview every candidate ourselves and check references with prior schools and supervisors. You interview a vetted shortlist and make every final decision. The screen was designed by our founder, Robert Flom, a former K-12 teacher.
- Competing schools. No. One partner per market. Once we are working with your school or district, we won't take on a directly competing school in your area. The educators we recruit for you are never shared with a rival down the road.
- The cost of a permanent hire. Nothing. Every placement is temp-to-perm at no cost, with no conversion fee and no buyout.
- Results and references. At Odyssey Public Charter School in Wilmington, Delaware: 120+ placements and a 95% fill rate on day-to-day substitutes, a 40%+ improvement over the previous provider. At First Philadelphia: 100% retention of the certified special education teachers we placed. Eight signed letters from superintendents, principals and HR directors are published in full on our references page, and the case studies give the detail.
- When a placement is not right. Temp-to-perm lets you evaluate a professional on the job before you commit, at no cost to your school. If someone isn't right, we make it right. Replacements are included in the engagement, and we stay involved for the life of the placement.
Elias Pappas, CEO of Odyssey Charter School, wrote in his signed letter: "Their innovative temp-to-perm clause has allowed us to assess the suitability of referred professionals before making permanent hiring decisions, all at no cost to the school." Lennita Porter-Linen, Director of Human Resources Recruitment and Retention at Bridgeton Public Schools, wrote in June 2026: "I recommend Focused Staffing Group without reservation."
Bring the scorecard and score us the way you score everyone else. Book a 30-minute call and ask us all 7. If a seat is open today, send a staffing request with the role and the building.
At a glance
A strong answer vs a weak answer
| Question | A strong answer | A weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Are clearances and the credential file finished before I meet a candidate? | Names every check your state requires, shows the verified certificate or license, and sends the complete file with the candidate | "We start the paperwork once you choose someone" |
| 2. How long from my request to a start? | Days or weeks for your role, tied to a named school where it happened | "It depends," or "tomorrow" for a certified role with no file to show |
| 3. Who recruits and interviews the candidates you send me? | The agency recruits for your opening, interviews every candidate itself, calls references and sends a shortlist. You decide | Résumés forwarded from a job board, and the screening left to you |
| 4. Do you supply competing schools in my area? | "No. One client per market, in writing" | "We work with every district in the county" |
| 5. What does it cost to hire the person permanently? | "Nothing. No conversion fee and no buyout, and it is in the agreement" | A fee schedule, a minimum number of hours, or "we will work that out later" |
| 6. What are your fill and retention results, and who can I call? | A fill rate and a retention figure tied to a named school, with signed letters and a reference call before you sign | "High 90s" with no school attached, and references after the contract |
| 7. What happens when a placement is not right? | A named contact, a replacement included in the engagement, and time to evaluate before any permanent hire | "Email support," a new search fee, or a minimum term you pay for either way |




